4703 East Lake Road, Erie PAMade fresh every morning since 1977(814) 898-1433
Gary’s Superette

Open Tue–Sat till 9 · Sunday till 7 · closed Monday

World famous
garlic parmesan
pepperoni balls

Delivery if you’d rather not talk to anyone.

49

Years on
this corner

2

Generations
of the family

Daily

Dough made
by hand

pepperoni balls, fresh from kitchen to table

Fifty years — Jan 1, 2027

Same corner
same recipe

Open every day but Monday

Monday we rest

  • Sun

    XL pizza, 12 wings & 1 lb. boneless39.99

    Add onAny two hot subs12.99

  • Tue

    Two XL 1-topping pizzas19.99

    Add onAny two appetizers9.99

  • Wed

    Any two hot subs12.99

    Add onXL pizza, 12 wings & 1 lb. boneless39.99

  • Thu

    Chicken wings, each1.09

    Add on2 lb. boneless wings19.99

  • Fri

    XL pizza & 24 wings36.99

    Add on2 lb. chicken tenders14.99

  • Sat

    Two XL 1-topping pizzas19.99

    Add onAny two appetizers9.99

The one thing we’re known for

Dough,
pepperoni,
mozzarella,
nothing else.

Rolled by hand before the store opens and fried in batches all day, so there’s a hot one waiting most hours. People drive across Erie for them, ship them to relatives, and order them by the dozen for graduations, tailgates and Sunday get-togethers alike.

Single — hot nowMini Pepperoni Ball Party Trays
1 day advance notice

Also a real corner store

Pot Of Gold Milk, Northern Scoop Ice Cream, Lottery, Pa Legal Skill Games, Drinks, and more

High quality food at lower prices — plus the household basics you forgot at the big store, and a few machines in the back if you’re feeling lucky.

  • Cold drinks
  • Snacks & candy
  • Lottery & scratch-offs
  • Pot of Gold milk & baked goods
  • Fresh sliced lunch meats
  • Skill games
the same corner, coming up on fifty years

Since 1977

Two generations,
one corner,
no franchise

Gary opened on East Lake Road because the neighborhood needed a store that stayed open late and knew your name. The pepperoni balls started as a way to use the dough left over from pizza night. Forty-nine years later they’re the reason people show up — and the store still closes on Mondays so the family can have a day.

  1. 1977

    Doors open. Groceries, cold pop, a small deli case.

  2. 1980s

    The pepperoni ball goes on the board. Word travels.

  3. Today

    Second generation behind the counter, same oven schedule.

“Always great pizza and wings! The staff is kind and easy to talk to and I love how fast we can get in and out! We will definitely be back!”
Thomas B. · Google review
“Great prices and great food. If you’re looking for a pizza, wings, subs, or any guilty pleasure. This would be a stop to make!”
Joe C. · Google review
“My wife and I had the best pepperoni balls EVER at the Superette followed by playing some slot machines with great company and great service!”
James W. · Google review

Find us

4703 East
Lake Road
Erie, PA

Hours

MonClosed
Tue – Sat9am – 9pm
Sunday9am – 7pm